I My Me! Strawberry Eggs – Brilliance Surrounded By BS

(This is my review for Reverse Thieves‘ Secret Santa event.)

Hibiki Amawa dreams of becoming a teacher; to pay the rent, he applies for a job at a local junior high school, Seito Sannomiya Private School. However, his application is rebuffed because the school’s principal refuses to hire any men, believing them to all be base, lecherous creatures. To help Hibiki pay the rent, his landlord, Lulu Sanjo, concocts a way for Hibiki to dress and sound just like a woman so that he will be accepted. Hibiki begins teaching and combats the streak of misandry running through the school.

There is an identity crisis that defines Strawberry Eggs, and it isn’t between Hibiki’s identity as a man and a woman.

Strawberry Eggs is a frustrating series because streaks of brilliance often race through each episode. There are many great moments of gender identity satire: Take, for instance, when the school’s few boys are forced by the principal to clean the school pool. Hibiki helps out because he sympathizes with the boys; when some of the girls pass by, Hibiki asks them to help, but they respond, “What?! Why should we do a man’s work?!” The men are the ones being forced into a specific role (even if physical labor is “traditionally” the domain of men), while the women are free to do whatever the hell they want. Just a small taste, but the boys get a feel for how unfair socially-enforced roles are.

A staple of genderbending comedy is when the crossdressing man notices guys checking him out and leering at him all day and grows uncomfortable with how he is being objectified; it’s neither an original point nor an original joke, but somehow it is always fun to see, just because it involves a character’s expectations being shaken up. And perhaps the best episode of the series involves the boys rising up in protest of one of their own being taken in for questioning due to what they perceive as an unfair anti-male bias. What makes this episode particularly interesting is that their pseudo-coup is not entirely just, nor is the stance Hibiki takes in reaction to it entirely good; but it’s understandable as a reaction to authoritarianism.

But the problem with all these interesting bits is that Strawberry Eggs lacks the — for lack of a better term — balls to go all the way with its satire.

The show never really decides whether it wants to be a cutting social satire or a light, breezy comedy. Every storyline that could potentially something really interesting or clever is resolved in typically melodramatic, glossy fashion. It wouldn’t irk me so much if the show itself didn’t take the time and care to raise viewer expectations and then shit all over them with nonsense. That’s the really frustrating part of the series: It really COULD be something special if just a bit more effort were put into the writing; instead, every episode is content to go partway with interesting satire and fill out the rest of the time with boring romance and anime bullshit.

I don’t think I would have had as big a problem with that indecision if the comedy weren’t so bad, too. Genderbending comedy can often be hilarious because misunderstandings = comic gold. (Just look at Some Like it Hot, one of the funniest movies ever made.) There are definitely moments like that peppered throughout Strawberry Eggs; however, there’s also plenty of dumb, tired anime comedy to go around. Like, hey, this one character is really clumsy and trips a lot! These two creepy old guys like to stalk junior high school students and take naughty photos of them! And just for fun, we’ll throw in a few chaste panty shots! It’s doubly insulting because, again, the show displays wit and genuinely intelligent satire often enough to make the only acceptable reaction to the anime comedy, “. . . Really, show? Really?” At least something like Asu no Yoichi! keeps expectations low from the start. It’s just unfair to raise expectations and pull the rug out from under the viewer.

It was probably bound to happen eventually, however, because it’s not as if the initial premise is amazing. The school principal can never really be taken seriously because she is such an extreme, man-hating harpy. That is literally her only trait. She even runs the school as if she is some sort of cult leader, exhorting the students with catch phrases like, “Love is all!” as she degrades all men. It’s difficult to muster the energy to even dislike her or indulge in the moments when she receives her comeuppance, because she’s such a goofy villain, kind of like Inari in Kuragehime. The assistant principal is basically a power-hungry woman who is threatened by Hibiki’s presence and is equally inconsequential.

I can’t totally fault the ending, though . . . it does make a decent attempt at showing how suffocating it can be for people who are outside the mainstream to live within a box set by other people’s expectations. (Fuko falling for Hibiki and then fretting about whether this means she is a lesbian, etc.) It’s not as good as the earlier satire because the drama is kind of clumsy, but it gets the job done. But while the ending thankfully goes in a slightly different direction than expected, it’s still kind of lame. People give speeches, people realize how oh so wrong they are and so on. It’s at least more bittersweet than a full blown, sappy happy ending, so the show has that going for it.

So, yeah, Strawberry Eggs is a total mixed bag, unfortunately. The good stuff makes it more fun and interesting to watch than a good deal of other series, but it’s difficult to not spend the entire time wishing the creators had just a bit more ambition with what they are doing. Also, I hate Akira. That guy is a fuckhead.

(For the curious, my other Secret Santa choices were True Tears and Romeo x Juliet. I chose Strawberry Eggs because I thought it was the one I would have been least likely to watch had I not been a part of Secret Santa.)

10 Responses to “I My Me! Strawberry Eggs – Brilliance Surrounded By BS”

  1. Interesting. This is one of those shows I’ve known about since the dawn of time but read nothing about. Now I know!

  2. I completely agree with how you feel about this anime. It needed to take it’s self just a little more seriously and it could have been a pretty great show. Not amazing but better than the dribble we got.

    • Yeah, if the actual process of writing was taken more seriously, this show could have been much better. It wouldn’t even take much of a tonal shift — just stick to more of the tone you see in the coup episode. It’s not a drastic difference at all, which makes it all the more frustrating.

  3. That was certainly a massive reaction but sometimes that is better than hardly any reaction (as far as writing goes). I must commend you for going all out and totally picking the show you would have not normally watched. While it turned out to be the show that was possibly the most off putting it was bold experiment on your part.

    “No one can serve two masters. Either he will hate the one and love the other, or he will be devoted to the one and despise the other.”

    I think I My Me! Strawberry Eggs goal was to try and play with a serious topic like gender roles while keeping the story light and breezy. But as you said by trying to do both at once it never really accomplished either. It is sad becuase had it been able to do both at once it might have really been able to be something special.

    Random Side Note: This is one of my youngest brother’s favorite anime. I am not sure what to make of that.

    Still I hope you had a good time over all and will participate again next year!

    – Hisui

    • Of course I’ll participate again! I was hoping to get some choices I had not heard of, but perhaps next year. And next year, I’ll probably again choose the one I would have been least likely to watch without Secret Santa. If there is a time to be bold, it’s when doing something like this.

      I would have been impressed if Strawberry Eggs had been able to accomplish both goals it set out to do, but I think those two are at odds in the first place. Keeping the story light and breezy just prevents the series from going far enough with the satire. Oh well.

  4. While we feel differently about the comedy being effective, I do have to admit it really was a let down to see it end the way it did. It had potential to become something much greater if emphasis had been placed on the issues that really made it interesting rather than in the annoying romantic crushes. I personally think it might as well had gone all the way for the sappy ending to make it at least happier if it didn’t go all the way for the satire theme. XD

  5. [...] reviewed I My Me! Strawberry Eggs recommended by [...]

  6. [...] borrow a phrase used by Shinmaru to describe Strawberry Eggs, B Gata H Kei is “brilliance surrounded by bullshit,” though perhaps not so extreme. [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 52 other followers

%d bloggers like this: